| |
The primary helical screw vendor in
Marin is Chris
Baumstagger (Woodacre, CA
415-488-4598); he uses AB Chance
helicals. Chris is a great guy. He
knows his stuff and he seems to have
most of the Marin business. He
provided a quote of $93,000, including
all concrete work, yet this fee would
not include reconnecting the house,
sheet rocking, finishing, etc.
Chris was a wealth of information. He
had a few specs he wanted to change
on the plans, for example, instead
of using sand under the slab, placed
there only for curing the concrete,
he was interested in using recycled
concrete ground into gravel. He
explained that I should describe this
project as a "voluntary foundation
upgrade" (which it was) to make
it easier to fast-track the plans. He
said he could build off the plans
that the engineer had provided, and
he didn't think that drilled piers
were the Cadillac. In his words,
"we helical guys end
up repairing too many of them."
More
than a year had passed since I had
spoken with Chris. With the foundation
project suddenly moving forward, I
reached out, leaving a few phone messages
saying I was ready to move on the
foundation upgrade. He didn't
get back. Perhaps it was because
I originally spoke with him back in
August of '06, and I might seem a
bit flakey. But the bottom line
was I needed to find other helical
screw vendors.
I asked Dave Olnes, my engineer for the parking space retaining wall. He provided three names.
I contacted George Walton, with Alameda Structural (510-301-4583). George explained that he had smaller equipment and if he could do the work it was less than 30 kips, otherwise it would have to be someone else.
I contacted Dan
Yust, at Accustruc
(925-872-4680). Dan had a few
comments. Could he begin at 7am
since he would be driving from the
East Bay? Did I plan to live
in the house? (He didn't recommend
it, since among other reasons, earthquake
risk.) He advised that he would
not suggest trying to save the pantry. It
would cost $5,000 to save and perhaps
$10,000 to rebuild from scratch. He
thought that it would cost about $1,000
to $1,500 per helical to use him. The
plan called for 13 verticals and three
diagonal helicals.
Finally I contacted
Tony Yudice at GeoSystems
(415-456-1492). Tony Yudice came
out, visited the property, and seemed
like a solid guy. He quoted $23,625. He
was in Marin, and seemed competent,
so I approached my structural engineer
to confirm that Tony's proposed Cyntech
screws would be OK. The engineer agreed,
under the condition that I increase
the thickness of the shaft, and increase
the diameter of the blades at the
end. Tony explained to me that this
was overkill, and that the larger
blades would probably not even penetrate
to the depth stipulated by the engineer,
given the dense clay that the soils
report indicated, but that he would
order the larger screws.
Footnote:
Tony was right. The screws were specked
to go 20'-30'. into the ground. They
went only 10'-15'. The helical portion
of this foundation upgrade cost more
than it should of, since I had to
order hardware that was not used.
|
|